Thursday, January 3, 2019

Carpool Karaoke and Sense of Place


I'm late to the game on this one. As we wrapped up 2018, a number of "best-of" articles cycled through our social media feeds. One in particular caught my attention. Given the darkness and gloom that seems to be pervading popular culture, The Gospel Coalition's "18 Pieces of Goodness in 2018 Pop Culture" by Brett McCracken provoked a click.

The article highlighted the story of Crazy Rich Asians, the reconciliation between Dan Crenshaw and Pete Davidson on Saturday Night Live, the much needed civility of the Great British Baking Show, the story of foster parenting as told through Instant Family, the sheer talent demonstrated by Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper as they sing "Shallow" in A Star Is Born, and the story of Mr. Rogers in Won’t You Be My Neighbor?, among others. Of everything included, James Corden's Carpool Karaoke with Paul McCartney stood out.

Again, I'm late in watching this segment, as it originally aired in June of 2018, but the interaction and commentary in the segment provoked some deeper thought. The segment made me think about the connections that the music of Paul McCartney and the Beatles had to their hometown of Liverpool, and how those type of connections were facilitated by the build environment and a sense of place. As an urban planner and lover of cities and memorable places, this is a concept called topophilia, a love for a place. McCracken wrote about the segment back in June 2018, highlighting the joyful longing that is prevalent as McCartney goes site to site through Liverpool:

Throughout the clip, McCartney describes what he remembers about Liverpool, about the contexts of the songs. He points out the room in his childhood home where he wrote “She Loves You” with John Lennon, and recalls how the house inspired lyrics in later songs like “A Day in the Life.” Driving on the literal Penny Lane (while singing the song), he points out the church—St. Barnabas—where he was once a choir boy. He stops by the barbershop made famous by the song.
“Penny Lane is in my ears and in my eyes,” he sings. And while most of us don’t have Penny Lane (or any other Liverpool site) in our ears and eyes, we can relate to the way that places shape us and stay with us.

It's hard to imagine what the music of The Beatles would have been had they not had the experience of place to inform their music and lyrics. Without a local barbershop on Penny Lane, they might be singing about a fast food place on a stroad. But, I shouldn't be too quick to dismiss other places. Surely, you can have meaningful connections with places that aren't like Liverpool, or like the towns and cities we all revere and love to visit, and in turn make many memories. You can sing about your grandmother's backyard, lakes and rivers, or a county fair. Country music is ripe with songs about corn fields, riversmixed use developments (okay, it's a stretch...) and Walmart parking lots. People certainly have meaningful connections to fairly mundane places, and there's not a loss of dignity in living somewhere without the richness of idyllic cities and towns.

But, I'd argue that rich places can give us a finer palate of memories and observations. These fine grained places evoke memories that can't be replicated anywhere else. That was part of McCracken's thoughts about the segment back in June:
Thinking of these childhood experiences brings me joy, not because I want to replicate them but because they cannot be. The joy is in the longing for these things, their irretrievability.

I don't remember the feeling I had when walking into the produce section in a Walmart in Virginia, where I lived for a while after college. But I do remember what it was like walking into the Ferry Building in San Francisco, and walking through their farmer's market. There's not another Ferry Building, but there are thousands of Walmarts, and they typically all look the same. While this is probably an extreme example, it's emblematic of why many city planners and architects strive to create places that aren't cookie cutter in style or design, and that facilitate human interaction. What's more is that rich places often attract people and allow us to use our senses.

There's a difference in the experience one has within a city or neighborhood on foot and within a particular radius of your home or a destination compared to what which you might have as you drive in a car fixed behind a windshield. Eric Jacobsen summarizes this well in his book, The Space Between, in that "the accelerated speeds in which cars propel our bodies through the environment means that we receive limited sensory input from the landscape outside of our cars." In addressing exurban areas, Jacobsen continues: "The exurban environment is not only engineered for the convenience of automobiles but also usually fails to accommodate this kind of sensory exploratory delight that we seek while walking."

Proximity matters in this discussion. It's why we're prone to forget what places look like as we sit in our car, but are probably more likely to remember places as we walk them. That's what we saw in Paul McCartney as he recounted his old neighborhood; the barbershop that inspired lyrics for Penny Lane, the church where he sang in the choir, or his childhood house at 20 Forthlin Road. Now, I know you're thinking, "But this whole discussion is related to driving through a city." Yes, but the memories being discussed are cultivated from something different, not the car rides (lifts?) that Paul, John, Ringo and George might have shared in Liverpool.

Generations can certainly be thankful for The Beatles and their music. But we can thank the planners, architects and city builders in Liverpool for giving four young lads an interesting landscape to base their songs. The sense of place for Paul McCartney offered him a way to connect with others, but also as Jacobsen writes, "temporarily with those who have preceded us and those who will succeed us through holding memories." The resultant music does much the same.

38 comments:

  1. Nice blog. Find best coupons deals on the link below
    promo Code

    ReplyDelete
  2. Packers and Movers Pune Provide High Quality ***Household Shifting, Home/Office Relocation, Insurance, Packing, Loading, ###Car Transportation Service Pune and High experiences, Top Rated, Safe and Reliable, Best and Secure Packers and Movers Pune Team List. Get ✔✔✔Affordable Rate Charts and Compare Quotation and Save Money and Time @ Packers And Movers Pune

    ReplyDelete
  3. This particular is usually apparently essential and moreover outstanding truth along with for sure fair-minded and moreover admittedly useful My business is looking to find in advance designed for this specific useful stuffs… caseificio pienza

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your blog post is very good, I got to learn something new from this blog post. Thanks for sharing this use full article
    vist and read more details
    https://makeawikipage.net/

    ReplyDelete
  5. Searching For Udaipur Escort Services Girls In One Place
    Udaipur is rapidly growing into a top business hub. You'll chill and have some fun The independent Udaipur Escort girls from below are readily available to make sure that your trip to Rajasthan is memorable.We offers a primary class Udaipur Escorts Service which will make sure that your security and privacy is maintained.
    Udaipur Escorts Service
    Udaipur Escort

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for posting this info.
    Aerocity Escorts
    Escorts in karol bagh
    Lajpat Nagar Escort Service
    Malviya Nagar Call Girls
    Call Girls in Connaught Place
    Escorts Service in Punjabi Bagh
    Mahipalpur Escorts Service
    I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It has a good meaning. If you always live positively, someday good things will happen. 토토사이트Let's believe in the power of positivity. Have a nice day.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey, Our Sexy Escorts in Mahipalpur Will Teach You The Real Meaning of Living a Life With Satisfaction in Sex Desire From Top to Bottom With a Completely Genuine Guarantee. Prepare Yourself To Meet Our Elegant and Hot Babes Because Mahipalpur Escorts Will Give You High Voltage Of Electrifying in the Room and On the Bed.
    Mahipalpur Escorts 
    Escorts in Mahipalpur
    Delhi Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nice post thanks' for sharing this. your information is very useful. Thankyou so much your image is beautiful. To know more visit at:- Skyscanner customer service.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Usually, I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man, Keep it up.
    Moreover, if you are looking for professional logo design services, check this out.
    Buy Logo

    ReplyDelete
  11. If you're in New Delhi, then don’t forget to celebrate your night party Call Girls in Paharganj. it's one among the foremost famous areas in Delhi, where many PaharGanj escorts provides their services. If you're in need of a horny woman with whom you'll take a tour of this city or with whom you'll satisfy your desires, then these Escorts Service in Paharganj are always able to serve you. Just confirm that you simply can contact us and within no time, we'll provide the simplest escort at your home. These escorts are totally amazing and that they can do things that you simply never expected from anyone.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Welcome to Delhi Mahipalpur Escort agency, We are the Leading Delhi escort agency. we provide the simplest Call Girls in Mahipalpur. On the off chance that a person who is anxious to urge the acute delight joy from Mahipalpur nightlife to the fullest can will excite our women who are Sleek lovely enticing, delightful, soft, and completely Sexy and gaiety with nature, our young and talented female offer even to the foremost simple man an exquisite blessedness Mahipalpur escort services. Employing our Escort Service in Mahipalpur is quite basic. Our Girls are well trained to deliver top quality services who they offered.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Welcome to the Delhi's ideal escorts organization who are serving the sexual delight from most up-to-date five years. we've the Exceptional Call Girls in Connaught place to form your each desire finish. you'll feel exceptionally self-inspired with our a la mode and hot escorts who make your fantasy full fill. we've the Independent CP Call Girls and furthermore Escorts in Connaught Place for demonstrating you the sexual happiness.
    Our Connaught Place call girls The overwhelming majority of the overall Population think what are the many job of Escorts Services in Connaught Place in their life.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Looking for Call Girls Service in Aerocity Hotels? during a city which is shrouded in mystery, your choice of Call girls in Aerocity will usually come from Aerocity and another a part of countries, though other come from China and Russia. Surprisingly there's an excellent nightlife in Aerocity, with much of the action happening round the nightclub, where you'll also find it easy to seek out a Call Girls in Aerocity, alongside prostitutes and escorts. The Bar has quite reputation for locating women, and therefore the Sheraton Hotel area is additionally known for its escorts.
    We didn't encourage prostitution in Aerocity, Delhi. We are only an Escorts agency, where local and foreign girls work as an associate & they're able to work as escort service in Aerocity.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Escort Service in Nehru Place has provided a spread of opportunity of entertainment for several individuals and it's the proper sort of service for the individuals who are hoping bent have significant visit to the town of Nehru Place. it's been gaining several thousands of people from round the world with the aim of offering of some useful services. Nehru Place escort and prostitute service discovered different pleasant service through which a number of the main options for entertainment are discovered thus far. Nehru Place Escort and Call girls in Nehru Place has continually trying to mention the energy that you simply have lost much earlier and it's the aim a number of you'd surely wish to have such sorts of service.

    ReplyDelete
  16. There are various reasons for you to travel for Escort Service in Chanakyapuri. First of all, if you're looking forward to refresh yourself physically and mentally, then there are often nothing better than the corporate of Independent Chanakyapuri Escorts. Their quality service is probably going to revive your senses to the fullest. Once you hire them they're going to lookout of everything. you'll either lead them or allow them to lead within the journey. they're going to attend any length to offer you the last word comfort within the best way possible.
    Experience a tremendous night with Call Girls Chanakyapuri

    ReplyDelete
  17. Aerocity, is one among the foremost popular area near Delhi Airport. Aerocity and Mahipalpur have attracted the hospitality industry and now have over 150 hotels catering thousands of individuals during a single day. Amongst the various services available in Aerocity, we provide Call Girls in Aerocity Escorts services available 24 hours of the day. we've beautiful available in Aerocity, New Delhi who would be happy to travel out on a date or in an occasion with you. These escorts aren't only beautiful in their looks, but also educated, working professionals and other individuals coming from various other background.
    Escort Service in Aerocity

    ReplyDelete
  18. Every man has some secret desires, which they need to full fill as soon as possible. Just believe it, you're close to accompany Delhi Escorts anywhere else, where nobody getting to disturb you. that's the sole time or personal space that peoples want to measure.
    Why Only accompany Escort Service in Delhi ?
    Call Girls in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  19. If you're looking forward to releasing stress from your daily, monotonous life, then consult an escort service. To consider escort services, the Lajpat Nagar escorts service would be the simplest option for you. These Escort Service in Lajpat Nagar are extremely charming, sensual and attractive. Their faces are so pretty, that you simply will keep watching them for hours and never get bored. you would possibly be experiencing wet dreams in the dark .
    Call Girls in Lajpat Nagar

    ReplyDelete
  20. Are you guys exploring modern, impressive Delhi Escort Service in Delhi? We questioned this because we are suitable for conducting premium class and pretty Delhi Call Girls for your satisfaction. If you've got been lonely for an extended time, so some time has begun. We are here to supply the foremost essential services in Delhi to you. Yes, we are talking escort services in Delhi, which has imperialism of the cutest girls within the city. We penetrate the intensity of your heart to watch your wants, and this is often what keeps us better to the remainder of others. it's difficult to be alone during this exotic city of the state .
    Call Girls in Delhi could be a far better choice for a few space for spending class time and enjoying romantic dates. the foremost satisfying part is that these expert love-makers are accessible at rock bottom rates. If you're looking for entertainment here, so what might be better than selecting an escort girl in Delhi?

    ReplyDelete
  21. Welcome to the destination of life describing it's never complete without a partner. every one should have some needfulness of a partner in their life. a number of the lads are lucky they need more friends and that they are proud of their needfulness. But there are many that have the aim to still found their final destination. Welcome to the planet of the incredible lifetime of Call Girls in Mahipalpur. You’ll have your true companion for any event you've got within the world. Our Mahipalpur Escorts provides an entrancing choice for a high-quality time during a city of sovereign people.
    Escort Service in Mahipalpur were making real-time opportunities to supply a magical companionship for the critical phase of the meeting. Now, brooding about the premium escorts service, enjoy the creamy Mahipalpur Escorts Service with our female escorts. you'll feel the important joy of companionship which may offer you perfect happiness and privacy. We are covering each and each aspect to gratify your needs.

    ReplyDelete
  22. After browsing a true tedious work schedule on day to day , men would have the natural wants for a few kind of relaxation and happiness. it's very obvious that the women having the glamorous appearance and desirability would be ranking within the higher position compared to the standard individuals within the list. Such is that the case with the women performing at our agency and therefore the time spend under their guidance is actually fascinating enough to quench the lusty matters of men. Independent call girls in Connaught place is understood to be the foremost intriguing experts being the perfect choice for in call also as outcall mode of services.
    It would be very easy and cozy to possess these enchanting hotdog babes in your arms as they're highly cooperative in nature and behavior. There would be few loss incurred by the purchasers to possess these ladies involved in Escort Service in Connaught place as their intimate partners who have the capabilities of providing the utmost level of erotic entertainment.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The girls are entertaining and sparking they skills to charge your body. They like to entertain new peoples who are affected by a stressful life. all of them wish to provide you with the pleasure of a high level. we offer you together with your choice and desirable Escorts in Paharganj for the acute sex. Our agency has many Call girls in Paharganj who are from a special community. a number of the women are a university student, busty ramp models and therefore the hot housewives who are trying to find hardcore sex.
    The girl will satisfy your sexual needs and take you the peak of utmost pleasure. all of them girls love, to be frank, or close with strangers, they not want to waste time with an uneventful life and she or he loves the thrills of the sexual comrade. Our Escorts Service in Paharganj are highly qualified and well mannered, you'll also get her for the occasions and therefore the parties.
    Click here > > paharganj escort

    ReplyDelete
  24. This site seems to inspire me a lot. Thank you so much for organizing and providing this quality information in an easy to understand way. I think that a healthy era of big data can be maintained only when such high-quality information is continuously produced. And I, too, are working hard to organize and provide such high-quality information. It would be nice to come in once and get information. 토토사이트먹튀

    ReplyDelete
  25. Post is really a nice and informative.
    Regards :
    best motorcycle helmets 2021

    ReplyDelete
  26. Sometimes the weather can play a greater role in a game, however, than the other factors listed above. For example, if a team that is expected to have a very good season is without a doubt having the best player in the NFL at the time, then this may cause the home team to fall behind early and then lose.Visit us at สมัครเว็บบอล.

    ReplyDelete
  27. A good hybrid mattress will have a combination of cushioning layers, which provide pressure relief, and individually wrapped spring coils that reduce motion transfer and provide support. Read on to see which mattresses made our Best hybrid mattress rating.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thanks for sharing your blog. It is very helpful to us . We share some information regarding Aerocity escorts .The common sex moves with cutting edge stunts to assist you with arriving at the most significant level of sex of Mahipalpur escorts.
    Mahipalpur Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  29. Call young ladies in Call Girls whatsapp number in Pune will invest some quality energy with you at whatever point you are free.Cheap Call Girls in Pune She will offer you unqualified love and care both!Bengali Call Girls in Agra She can full fill all your shrouded delight and in the event that you need, she can offer you exotic body knead.Air hostess Call Girls in Dehradun The majority of the young ladies are experienced and they realize how to make you agreeable.Air hostess Call Girls in Dehradun Attempt this administration now and get total fulfillment.Call Girls whatsapp number in Gurgaon Think about the cost and after that pick the best escort administration effectively.

    ReplyDelete
  30. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  31. 훌륭하게 쓰여진 기사, 만약 모든 블로거들이 당신과 같은 내용을 제공한다면, 인터넷은 훨씬 더 좋은 장소가 될 것이다.메리트카지노

    ReplyDelete
  32. This is amazing, thanks for the share. Also, visit our website if you are looking to purchase logo:

    Purchase Logo

    ReplyDelete
  33. To find out why you have hair loss, you may also need a blood test. This can check for things going on in your body that may be causing your hair loss. Some patients need a procedure called a scalp biopsy. Your dermatologist can quickly and easily take what is needed for the scalp biopsy during the consultation. If you want to know fue hair transplant cost in usa visit us.

    ReplyDelete